Friday, 28 October 2011



CAMERON'S CHANGE WILL NOT BE SO SIMPLE

British prime minister David Cameron's announcement that Commonwealth
nations have approved a change to the rules of succession to allow
first-born daughters and heirs who marry Catholics to inherit the throne is
wrong and is blatant politicking on his part. Despite the media headlines,
nothing whatsoever has been changed.

In the first instant the issues have nothing to do with the Commonwealth as
a whole, but only those countries of which the Queen is sovereign. Moreover
not all prime ministers are present, and even if they are all in favour,
they cannot themselves commit the parliaments of their respective
countries,
most of which would have changed by the time any legislation is presented.

Furthermore, as far as opening marriage to royals is concerned, there are a
number of Acts that would need to be amended, including the Act of
Settlement, the Bill of Rights, the Coronation Oaths Act, the Crown in
Parliament Act, the Act of Union and the Royal Marriages Act. Getting such
amendments through the British parliament, and especially the House of
Lords, will be difficult enough, but on top of this, it will be necessary
for all the parliaments of the remaining fifteen realms, i.e.: Antigua and
Barbuda, Australia, the Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Canada, Grenada,
Jamaica,
New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint
Vincent and the Grenadines, Solomon Islands and Tuvalu plus possibly also
of
the six Australian States, because the Queen is also separately their
Queen.

The British prime minister's proposals are not really about discrimination,
for all religions aspire to protect their beliefs and can therefore be said
to discriminate. What Mr Cameron is actually proposing is to end the
Protestant Succession and ultimately the monarchy in England.

Philip Benwell MBE
(National Chair - Australian Monarchist League)