Friday, 22 March 2013


Anti-Semitism Discovered In the Muslim Community: 


Shocker!

Douglas Murray’s blog post in the Spectator caught my eye yesterday, in which he points out a must-read article in the HuffingtonPost by Mehdi Hasan. No, really:
Hasan felt compelled for some reason to speak out against Lord Ahmed’s rant about how a Jewish conspiracy caused his conviction for killing someone while driving and texting at the same time.
To claim that your jail sentence for dangerous driving is the result of a Jewish plot is bigoted and stupid. The peer has since been suspended from the Labour Party and forced to stand down as a trustee of the Joseph Interfaith Foundation. I’m not sure how many “Jewish friends” he has left – if, that is, he had any to begin with.
Full disclosure: I know Lord Ahmed and have defended him in the past. In 2007, he flew out to Sudan to help free the schoolteacher Gillian Gibbons from the clutches of the odious Islamist regime in Khartoum. In 2009, an Appeal Court judge noted how the peer had “risked his life trying to flag down other vehicles to stop them colliding with… his car”. He is not a latter-day Goebbels. But herein lies the problem. There are thousands of Lord Ahmeds out there: mild-mannered and well-integrated British Muslims who nevertheless harbour deeply anti-Semitic views.
No kidding.
The truth is that the virus of anti-Semitism has infected members of the British Muslim community, both young and old. No, the on-going Israel-Palestine conflict hasn’t helped matters. But this goes beyond the Middle East. How else to explain why British Pakistanis are so often the most ardent advocates of anti-Semitic conspiracies, even though there are so few Jews living in Pakistan?
The fact that a visceral hatred of Jews and conspiracy-mongering is rife within the Mohammedan communities around the world is old news to people here, and surely it’s not a stunning revelation to Hasan, either. The real question is, what will the BBC do about this?
To be honest, I’ve always been reluctant to write a column such as this. To accuse my fellow Muslims of being soft on the scourge of anti-Semitism isn’t easy; I feel as if I am ‘dobbing in’ the community, telling tales to the non-Muslim teacher. Nor do I particularly want to assist the English Defence League in its relentless campaign to demonise all Muslims, everywhere, as extremists and bigots.
We aren’t. And we’re not all anti-Semites. But, as a community, we do have a ‘Jewish problem’. There is no point pretending otherwise.
So it’s not news to Hasan after all. He’s been aware of it for a very long time. How about the BBC? We all remember how they leapt to support Baroness Warsi when she lamented that Islamophobia had“passed the dinner table test” in Britain. They made sure to do a Have Your Say on it. The World Service audience got their own Have Your Say, asking who was responsible for Islamophobia. I don’t need to reel out a laundry list of all the news reports, radio shows, and drama programming the BBC has produced in the last few years trying to encourage people to accept Islam, and even welcome it. More recently, in keeping with the BBC’s remit to foster social cohesion, they promoted the national“Wear a Hijab Day”, to encourage girls of all races and religions to spend the day embracing this aspect of Mohammedan culture, to learn how “the other” lives and so bring communities closer together. Some of us joked at the time that we wouldn’t be holding our breath for the BBC to do a “Wear a Yarmulke” day. But now it seems like this would be the perfect opportunity for them to use the special, unique powers and influence of the BBC to take a stand against the anti-Jewish sentiment that has equally passed the dinner table test in Britain. And it’s not just at the dinner parties Mehdi Hasan goes to, either.
Hasan seems to be aware that the Palestinian situation is not necessarily the sole reason for the hatred of Jews amongst his co-religionists. He may not know just how far back it goes (before the creation of Israel, in fact), and one has to equally wonder if anyone at the BBC shares his awareness. Only time will tell. I don’t think Hasan’s purpose here is to delve into the history of anti-Semitism in the Muslim World or anything like that, so there’s no problem with him not going into it. However, the BBC does do history and background, when it suits them, so there’s no excuse for them not to get into it in detail.
If the BBC doesn’t respond to this with even a fraction of the energy with which they’ve attacked the problem of Islamophobia, it will be a clear failure of their Charter-bound duty. Whether or not it’s evidence of a similar epidemic of anti-Jewish sentiment at the BBC remains to be seen.
Bookmark the permalink.

23 Responses to Anti-Semitism Discovered In the Muslim Community: Shocker!

  1. Not to mention the Guardian, who last year had to apologise for two Anti-Semitic articles by, I think, Deborah Orr. Anti-Semitism is rife on the Left, and their levels of denial about it are matched only by their eternal denial of Stalin & co.
       19 likes
  2. Dr Foster says:
    I agree with much of this article. But Mehdi Hasan is not the chair of a major political party and a member of the Upper House, he’s a political journalist and, one might argue, not a terribly important one. So his comments are eminently less newsworthy than those of Baroness Warsi and it would not be fair to judge the BBC’s response to this article – whatever it should turn out to be – as if the two were equivalent.
       9 likes
    • David Preiser (USA) says:
      Except Hasan is a regular on the BBC, and they see him as an important voice. I take your point that he’s not anywhere near the high public position that Warsi was at the time, which is why I’m asking for a mere fraction of the coverage from the BBC, and not an equivalent response. Surely you can agree that the BBC should at least acknowledge there’s a problem.
         9 likes
    • stewart says:
      But the man deserves credit .It took balls to write that article.I was going to make a joke along the lines of
      ” as much for being a leftist as a muslim”
      But the truth is that as leftist apostate, the worst he could expect is the same ‘knuckle dragging racist’ ad hominem that you or I might get.As a muslim his risk of physical attack,though small,is real.
         6 likes
      • chrisH says:
        I agree Stewart.
        For a Muslim to say such things is quite a risk, but one downplayed by the useless Left and the Guardian huggers at the BBC.
        Hasan is a blowhard creep in the main…but I have a new found respect for this individual act of courage.
        I`m grateful for small mercies I know, but that`s no reason not to give credit…heck Question Time even had a tweeter attached who was NOT a lefty…this a first?
           6 likes
      • David Preiser (USA) says:
        Absolutely. He even admits it was a difficult decision to make, and why.
           2 likes
  3. john in cheshire says:
    From what I understand islam has been anti-Jew from the beginning of its creation. And reading translated extracts, it is deeply embedded in that book of theirs.
       12 likes
    • David Preiser (USA) says:
      True enough, and all the more reason to accept that Israel is not the only cause, but the conspiracy craziness is a fairly modern phenomenon, which is what Hasan was really getting at.
         8 likes
    • Jack de says:
      The uncomfortable examination of Islamic doctrines and history is required in order to understand the enduring phenomenon of Muslim Jew hatred, which dates back to the origins of Islam. Even if all non-Muslim Judeophobic themes were to disappear miraculously overnight from the Islamic world, the living legacy of anti-Jewish hatred, and violence rooted in Islam’s sacred texts – -Koran, hadith, and sira — would remain intact. The assessment and understanding of Islamic anti-Semitism must begin with an unapologetic analysis of the anti-Jewish motifs contained in these foundational texts of Islam. We can no longer view Muslim Jew hatred — including annihilationist strains of this apocalyptic hatred — as a “borrowed phenomenon,” seen primarily, let alone exclusively, through the prism of Nazism and the Holocaust, the tragic legacy of Judeophobic Christian traditions, or “The Protocols of the Elders of Zion” from Czarist Russia. ……
         4 likes
  4. Roland Deschain says:
    Uh-oh David. You’ve mentioned Muslims. Cue the usual accusations of racism.
       9 likes
    • David Preiser (USA) says:
      I know. And I’m aware of the irony of my having recently wished for a one-week moratorium on posts about it. Cue charges of hypocrisy as well, I guess. But as the saying goes, “Events, dear boy, events.”
         10 likes
      • noggin says:
        i wish for nothing more than, hearing zilch
        zero, squat, nothing from this dangerous ideology at all.
        but as it is a a dangerous ideology, the most dangerous ideology, and keeps driving its adherrents, to murdering, planning to murder, gang raping, stoning, beating, mutilating, subdugating all that don t follow its retarded worldview – week on week,on week
        Attempting to silence writers, filmakers, bloggers etc that tell the truth about it
        and poisons its next generation to continue
        its fascist ideal.
        it deserves everthing it gets, which isn t nearly enough.
           10 likes
      • Joshaw says:
        To balance things up a bit, I understand that those bloody Buddhists have been attacking a certain minority in Burma.
           0 likes
  5. noggin says:
    has infected? …. brit muslim community?
    Islam has infected everyone of its adherrents
    with jew hatred … if they read their own book,
    oops … their own ahem “perfect book” that is.
    or maybe follow their “perfect example”, mind you they d have to go a bit he s known to have beheaded 200, yep! thats 200 at a time … feel the love eh!.
    ah! … and all that deliberately diversionary, apologetic pap from M,(kaffirs are animals) Hasan too, and i thought muslim groups were worse than useless on stopping antisemitism by mistake :-D
    and i thought it was the jooos that were the nazis? too
    i couldn t find anything on bbc news about it either?
    obama visit and all that?
    i wonder if 5lives “panto” cambell, could get the UAF back on his “fascism” show to explain this?
    http://news.yahoo.com/hate-graffiti-sprayed-jewish-homes-tel-aviv-065408702.html
    Swastikas and “death to Jews” spray-painted on Jewish homes in Tel Aviv.
    or … how about the “yearning for peace” pallies , celebrating obamas visit with ……
    yep! … swastikas!
       12 likes
    • John Anderson says:
      I visited Bethlehem as a tourist 10 days ago. You can see from the background to this film that the town is perfectly prosperous. Smart cars, clean buildings and streets. The Arab bus from Jerusalem to Bethlehem was brand-new, air-con etc, just as comfortable as any other bus I travelled on in Israel.
      What is all this “pain the Israelis inflict on us every day ” that one of these idiots bleats about ? – I didn’t see any.
      These demos are just for media effect, they do not reflect the ongoing daily life of this Arab city.
         5 likes
    • +james says:
      Look at this nut job from America. He reckons that drawing a Mo cartoon is as bad a s burning down a Church. Cartoons the same as arson.
         4 likes
  6. Lynette says:
    The BBC in December 2003 simply wrote the Jews out of history .see how the complaint was eventually dealt with. if this is not anti semitism than what is ? ?
       7 likes
  7. Cosmo says:
    Didn’t his previous employer ( The New Statesman ) once have a cover showing a ” gold star of David dripping in blood “. Star of David = Jews, Gold = money, blood = child killers, the old old tropes, he was either working for them at the time and if he wasn’t he must have known about it but still chose to work for these Nazi’s. Don’t hold your breath on the BBBC doing anything on Islamic Jew hatred.
       10 likes
  8. Wokinghamblue says:
    Did anyone see Bowen on the news yesterday discussing a planned settlement? The venomous way he spat out that the pla would consider it a block to a two state solution if “they cover the area with houses for Jews” left me in no doubt of his leanings, disgusting.
       10 likes
  9. wallygreeninker says:
    Mehdi is understating it, perhaps because Muslim anti-semitism is too obvious to deny. The truth is that the Jews (all Jews, not just Israelis, as responsibility is taken to be collective) are currently being subjected to a sharia-ordained jihad. Western incursions into Iraq and Afghanistan were always meant to be temporary and in support of local ‘moderate’ but orthodox Muslims: defensive jihad (the type that is compulsary for all adult males) against the west might be treated as a moot point but a permanent invasion from outside dar al Islam coupled with a breach of their contract of subjugation by middle eastern Jews makes Israel definitely the real thing. Holy war, for Muslims, means the allah approved practices of massacre, rape, abduction and pillage and it is open season on the Jews.
       2 likes