Britannia Radio

EU OBSERVER 19.2.09

Czech president compares EU parliament to one-party state
The Czech president is not opposed to his country's membership of the
EU (Photo: European Parliament)

VALENTINA POP

/ BRUSSELS – Increasing the European Parliament's powers won't solve
EU's democratic deficit, since the bloc's legislature does not
represent any nation and allows for no political alternatives opposed
to EU integration, Czech President Vaclav Klaus told MEPs on Thursday
(19 February

Renowned for his critical stance towards Brussels and the Lisbon
treaty, Czech President Vaclav Klaus has questioned the authority of
the European Parliament visiting the EU capital, prompting a dozen
Socialist MEPs to leave the room.

"Are you really convinced that every time you take a vote, you are
deciding something that must be decided here in this hall and not
closer to the citizens, that are inside the individual European
states?" Mr Klaus asked.

He warned that the European Parliament currently lacked any
"political alternative" opposed to European integration, something
that resembled the one-party system of the Soviet Union.

Moreover, since there was no genuine "European demos," the democratic
deficit of the EU could not be solved by strengthening the role of
the European Parliament – a measure foreseen in the Lisbon treaty.
"This would, on the contrary, make the problem worse and lead to an
even greater alienation of the citizens of European countries from
the EU institutions," he said.

The solution, he explained later in a press conference, was "to
return many competences from the European Parliament to national
parliaments and from Brussels to national governments."

The Czech president stressed that he was not opposed to his country's
membership of the EU, since he saw no alternative to it and didn't
want to be "the bad guy," with all the "good guys inside the EU."

However, he argued that the "methods and forms of European
integration do, on the contrary, have quite a number of possible and
legitimate variants."

"There is no end of history," he said. "Neither the present status
quo, nor the assumption that the permanent deepening of the
integration is a blessing is – or should be – a dogma for any
European democrat. The enforcement of these notions ...is unacceptable."

In his view, the European Union should go back to the principles it
was based on – human freedom and economic prosperity through the
market economy and deregulation.

The current economic and financial crisis, was incorrectly depicted
as being caused by free market and lack of regulation. "In reality,
it is just the contrary – caused by political manipulation of the
market," he said.

People in eastern Europe, including Czechs, who lived half of the
20th century without freedom and in a "dysfunctional, centrally
planned economy" were particularly sensitive to the "tendencies
leading in other directions than towards freedom and prosperity," he
argued.

Asked about the remarks of President Nicolas Sarkozy, who has called
on French car makers to stay in France instead of setting up shop in
the Czech Republic, Mr Klaus said he would oppose "any ideas from
anyone suggesting the building of new barriers."

Mr Klaus also opposed any accelerated accession of his country to the
eurozone, being convinced that the Czech republic would have been
"worse off" if it were in the monetary union.

Chess play with Lisbon

Asked whether he would sign the Lisbon treaty if the Czech parliament
completed ratification of the document, the president compared
himself to a chess player who never announces his next move.

When questioned if the new Libertas party was one of the political
alternatives he was calling for, Mr Klaus answered that "Libertas is
against the Lisbon treaty. This is an important message that I fully
support."

He reiterated the idea that the Irish voters should not be bullied
into accepting the treaty, stressing that the idea of EU integration
was initially based on freedom and on equal rights for every country
– big or small.

"I hope we're not moving towards an Orwellian world where some are
more equal than others," he concluded.

Parliament's establishement outraged

The president of the European Parliament, German MEP Hans-Gert
Pottering [Not that dreadful man yet again! -cs] , a strong supporter
of the Lisbon treaty and EU integration, was visibly upset by Mr
Klaus' remarks.

Standing next to the Czech president after he delivered his speech,
Mr Poettering said: "It was your wish to speak in this house,"
adding: "You would not have been able to deliver this speech in a
parliament of the past."

"Your visit today is an expression of the diversity of opinions in
the EU," Mr Poettering added.

He did concede one point to the Czech president, saying that
decisions should be indeed taken closer to the citizen, but that it
was also the responsibility of national government to devolve powers
to regional and local authorities.

The co-president of the Greens, Daniel Cohn-Bendit, also a strong
promoter of EU integration, went so far as to propose Mr Klaus for a
"special carnival award in recognition of his efforts as provocateur
of the year."

"His speech to this house was a perfect source of festive amusement."